Argument from false premises facts for kids
An argument from false premises happens when someone uses a starting idea that isn't true to try and prove something. A false premise is like a wrong assumption or fact that forms the base of a logical argument. Because the starting idea (the premise) is incorrect, the final conclusion might also be wrong.
However, it's important to know that an argument can still be "valid" in its logic, even if its starting ideas are false. "Valid" just means the steps of the argument make sense, not that the starting ideas are actually true.
For example, imagine this argument:
- If the streets are wet, it has rained recently. (This is the first idea, or premise)
- The streets are wet. (This is the second idea, or premise)
- Therefore, it has rained recently. (This is the conclusion)
This argument seems logically correct. If the first two ideas were true, the conclusion would have to be true. But the first idea ("If the streets are wet, it has rained recently") can be false. Maybe someone hosed down the streets, or a street cleaner passed by, or a river flooded.
A simple check of the argument's logic won't show this mistake, because logic assumes all the starting ideas are true. This is why an argument based on false premises can be much harder to argue against than one with a clear logical error. To show it's wrong, you have to prove that its starting ideas aren't true.
Another tricky thing about arguments with false premises is that their conclusion can actually be true, even if the starting ideas are false. In the example above, it might actually have rained recently, and the streets might be wet. This doesn't make the first idea true, but it can make it harder for someone to prove that the argument is flawed.
Contents
What is a False Premise?
A false premise is a statement or idea that is presented as true but is actually incorrect. It's the starting point of an argument that isn't based on facts. Think of it as building a house on a shaky foundation. Even if your building plans are perfect, the house might still fall because the ground underneath isn't stable.
Why are False Premises Tricky?
False premises can be hard to spot because the rest of the argument might seem perfectly logical. People often focus on whether the steps of an argument make sense, rather than checking if the very first ideas are true.
- They can lead to wrong conclusions: If you start with a false idea, you can end up believing something that isn't true, even if your thinking process is otherwise sound.
- They can be hard to disprove: To show an argument with a false premise is wrong, you have to prove that the initial premise itself is false. This can sometimes be difficult, especially if the premise sounds believable or is widely accepted without proof.
- The conclusion might still be true: Sometimes, an argument with a false premise can accidentally lead to a true conclusion. This makes it even more confusing, as the truth of the conclusion might make people think the entire argument is correct.
How to Spot a False Premise
To avoid being tricked by arguments based on false premises, it's important to:
- Question assumptions: Always ask yourself if the basic ideas or facts presented at the beginning of an argument are actually true. Don't just assume they are.
- Look for evidence: Does the person making the argument offer proof or reliable sources for their starting ideas? If not, be cautious.
- Consider other possibilities: Like in the wet streets example, think about other reasons why something might be true. If there are many other explanations, the initial premise might be false.
Understanding false premises helps you think more critically about information you hear or read every day. It teaches you to look beyond just the logic and also check the facts.
Related pages
