Clark v. Board of School Directors facts for kids
Quick facts for kids Clark v. Board of Directors |
|
|---|---|
 |
|
| Court | Iowa Supreme Court |
| Decided | June 1868 |
| Citation(s) | 24 Iowa 266; 1868 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 17 |
| Case history | |
| Appealed from | Muscatine District Court |
| Case opinions | |
| Segregation of schools on the basis of race violates the Iowa Constitution. | |
| Case opinions | |
| Decision by | Chester C. Cole |
Clark v. Board of School Directors was an important case decided by the Iowa Supreme Court in 1868. The Court ruled that schools could not separate students based on their race.
In 1867, Susan Clark, a 13-year-old African American girl, sued the local school board in Muscatine, Iowa. She was not allowed to attend Grammar School No. 2 because it was only for white students. Susan argued that this separation went against Iowa law and the Iowa State Constitution.
Both the local trial court and the state district court agreed with Susan. The school board then appealed the decision to the Iowa Supreme Court. The Supreme Court agreed with the lower courts, saying that separating students by race was not allowed.
Contents
A Landmark Case for Iowa Schools
This case happened soon after the American Civil War. At that time, many places still had segregated schools. But the Clark v. Board of School Directors decision meant that schools in Iowa had to integrate. This happened almost 100 years before the famous Brown v. Board of Education case in 1954, which ended school segregation across the United States.
The Iowa Supreme Court decided that every school district in Iowa must provide education for all children. Schools could separate students based on where they lived, but not on their race. This ruling was very clear. Judge Chester C. Cole wrote that the Iowa Constitution said schools must educate "all the youths of the State." This meant schools could not choose which students to admit based on their color or background.
Susan's family was very involved in fighting for equal rights. Her brother, Alexander Clark, Jr., later became the first black graduate of the University of Iowa's College of Law. Her father, Alexander Clark Sr., was the second.
What Happened in the Case
The case was about Susan Clark, a 13-year-old African-American girl from Muscatine, Iowa. She was told she could not attend her neighborhood school because it was only for white children. Susan sued the school board. She said the school was breaking Iowa's laws and the state constitution by separating students.
The local court agreed with Susan. But the school board appealed the decision to the state Supreme Court. The Supreme Court supported the lower court's decision. This meant school segregation was not allowed. Judge Chester C. Cole stood by his decision. He said that segregated schools did not follow the Iowa Constitution. He believed schools had to educate all children.
It's important to know that in 1858, there was a law that allowed school boards to "provide for the education of the colored youths in separate schools." However, the Iowa Supreme Court later said this law was unconstitutional. They ruled that only the board of education could create a system of education, not the general assembly.
The Court's Decision
The Iowa Supreme Court agreed with the first court's decision. This meant Susan Clark was allowed to attend Grammar School No. 2. This ruling was very important because it was one of the first times a court said that "separate was not equal."
Judge Cole's Opinion
Judge Chester C. Cole wrote the main opinion for the court. He argued that separating people by race was like separating them by their nationality. He said that if schools could separate one group, they would have to separate all groups based on their background.
Judge Cole believed that all young people are equal under the law. He said that while school directors could decide things like school uniforms, they could not decide who could attend school if a student met all the requirements.
Judge Wright's Different View
Judge George G. Wright had a different opinion. He agreed that the constitution said all young people in the state should get an education. However, he thought school directors should have the main say in how schools were organized. He believed they could decide where children should go to school, as long as it was in their proper district.
Judge Wright said he understood that the law gave all children the right to attend common schools. He felt that the school directors in this case recognized this right. But he did not think the court should force the school to admit Susan to that specific school. He believed that if Susan could go to another school in her district, she had no reason to complain. He thought it was the school board's decision, not Susan's or her father's.
School Named for Susan Clark
In 2019, the Muscatine Community School District's Board of Education voted to name its new combined middle schools after Susan V. Clark. Starting in the 2020-2021 school year, the former West Middle School building became the Susan Clark Junior High School.
