Diana Gould–Margaret Thatcher exchange facts for kids
On May 24, 1983, a British schoolteacher named Diana Gould had a famous discussion with the Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher. This exchange was about the sinking of the Belgrano, an Argentine warship, during the 1982 Falklands War. Many people remember this moment as one of Britain's most important television events.
The Belgrano was a large ship that sank on May 2, 1982. Sadly, 323 lives were lost. Prime Minister Thatcher gave the order to attack the ship. This happened when the Belgrano was sailing near a special "exclusion zone" around the Falkland Islands. British submarines fired torpedoes at the ship. The sinking caused much debate. People argued if the ship was moving towards or away from the exclusion zone. Diana Gould believed it was sailing away. Later, in 2011, it was revealed that the Belgrano had actually been ordered to sail towards the zone.
The discussion between Thatcher and Gould became very well-known. Diana Gould kept asking why the order to sink the ship was given. This seemed to make the Prime Minister uncomfortable. People said it was "the day Margaret Thatcher met her match." Thatcher was reportedly upset that the BBC allowed such a question. Diana Gould later wrote a book about her experience.
Contents
Who Was Diana Gould?
Diana Sydney Gould was born on April 18, 1926, in Bristol, England. She was a very bright student. She studied geography at Newnham College, Cambridge, and did very well. She was also a talented athlete. She earned awards for hockey, swimming, and diving.
After college, Diana worked as a weather officer for the Women's Royal Naval Service. She later married Clifford Gould, who was also in the military. In 1955, Diana became a part-time physical education (PE) teacher. Her husband also became a teacher. They had four children. Diana had studied the Falklands and the Antarctic in college. Because of this, she had followed the news about the Belgrano sinking very closely.
The Nationwide Interview
On May 24, 1983, Prime Minister Thatcher appeared on a live TV show called Nationwide. She agreed to answer questions from regular people. Diana Gould had written to the show and was invited to participate. Before the show, she even called a Member of Parliament, Tam Dalyell, to get more information about the Belgrano sinking.
Thatcher was in the BBC studios in London. Diana Gould was in the BBC's Bristol studio. Diana was the fourth person to ask a question. She asked, "Mrs. Thatcher, why, when the Belgrano, the Argentinian battleship, was outside the exclusion zone and actually sailing away from the Falklands, why did you give the orders to sink it?"
Thatcher replied that the ship was "in an area which was a danger to our ships." Diana Gould insisted the ship was sailing away. Thatcher kept saying the ship was a danger. She said the full facts would be known in about 30 years. She also said, "I think it could only be in Britain that a Prime Minister was accused of sinking an enemy ship that was a danger to our navy, when my main motive was to protect the boys in our navy."
Diana Gould also suggested that the sinking stopped a peace plan. But Thatcher said the peace plan arrived after the sinking. Both women became quite annoyed with each other during the interview. Diana Gould told Thatcher, "That is not good enough." Thatcher replied, "Would you please let me answer?"
After the interview, Prime Minister Thatcher was reportedly very angry. Her husband, Denis Thatcher, was also upset. He complained to the BBC staff. This TV moment was later voted as one of the most memorable in British television history.
What Happened After?
The Belgrano Action Group
After her TV appearance, Diana Gould joined the Belgrano Action Group. This group was formed by people like Tam Dalyell. They wanted to find out more about the Belgrano sinking. In 1986, Diana helped organize a public meeting to discuss the event.
The Thorp Report
Prime Minister Thatcher had mentioned that the full facts would be known in 30 years. This might have been about a report she asked for. It was written by Major David Thorp, who worked with signals intelligence during the war.
This report, called The Sinking of the Belgrano, was never made public. However, Major Thorp wrote in his own book in 2011 that the Belgrano had been ordered to sail into the exclusion zone. It was meant to meet other ships, possibly for an attack. This was different from what the Argentine government had claimed. Thatcher had read this report. But she did not share the information with the public. Some believe she did not want to reveal how much Britain was listening in on enemy communications.
Images for kids
-
Diana Gould (left) speaking to Margaret Thatcher (right)
-
Naval forces in the South Atlantic, 1–2 May 1982
-
Location of Ascension Island
