The American Civil War had many brave leaders, but not all of them were officially recognized as generals by the Confederate government. This article talks about officers who acted as generals, leading troops in important battles, but whose appointments were never fully confirmed. It also includes state militia generals who fought for the Confederacy in their home states.
Sometimes, communication was difficult during the war. This meant that some officers who were appointed as generals by local commanders, like General E. Kirby Smith, never had their appointments officially approved by the Confederate President and Senate in Richmond.
After the important city of Vicksburg fell, it was hard for the Confederate government in Richmond to communicate with its forces west of the Mississippi River. General E. Kirby Smith, who was in charge of that area, appointed several officers as generals. He tried to get President Jefferson Davis to make these appointments official. While some were approved, at least nine officers appointed by Smith late in the war served as generals but were never officially confirmed.
Some Confederate officers are often called generals in history books, but their appointments were never fully completed or confirmed. This could be because their appointments were withdrawn, not approved by the Senate, or their official papers arrived after they had died. In some cases, promotions were given after an officer's death as a sign of respect. These officers are still important because of the commands they held or their actions in battle.
Name |
Rank |
Notes |
Ashby, Henry Marshall |
Colonel |
- He was a colonel in the 2nd Tennessee Cavalry.
- He was commissioned as a brigadier general in April 1865, but the official papers were never delivered.
|
Ashby, Turner |
Colonel
Brigadier General
May 23, 1862
unconfirmed at death |
- He was a colonel in the 7th Virginia Cavalry.
- He led cavalry during Stonewall Jackson's Valley Campaign in 1862.
- He was killed in action in June 1862. His promotion to brigadier general was not confirmed before his death.
|
Barry, John D. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
appointed August 2, 1864
unconfirmed
canceled a few days later |
- He was a colonel in the 18th North Carolina Infantry.
- He was wounded four times.
- He was appointed brigadier general in August 1864, but his appointment was canceled when his superior officer returned.
|
Bartow, Francis Stebbins |
Colonel
Brigadier General
posthumous |
- He was a colonel in the 8th Georgia Infantry.
- He was killed at the First Battle of Bull Run in July 1861.
- The Confederate Congress gave him the rank of acting brigadier general after his death as an honor.
|
Benton, Samuel |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: July 26, 1864
died before commission
received |
- He was a colonel in the 37th Mississippi Infantry.
- He was mortally wounded at the Battle of Atlanta in July 1864.
- He died before receiving his official papers as a brigadier general.
|
Bowles, Pinckney Downie |
Colonel |
- He was a colonel in the 4th Alabama Infantry.
- Some sources say he was commissioned brigadier general in April 1865, but this was after the Confederate Senate had stopped meeting.
|
Brevard, Jr. Theodore W. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: March 22, 1865
nom: March 28, 1865
unconfirmed |
- He was a colonel in the 11th Florida Infantry.
- He was one of the last officers President Jefferson Davis appointed as a general in March 1865, but it was never confirmed.
|
Browne, William Montague
"Constitution" |
Colonel
Brigadier General
temporary rank:
from November 11, 1864
unconfirmed: rejected |
- He was an aide to President Jefferson Davis.
- His nomination as a temporary brigadier general in November 1864 was rejected by the Confederate Senate.
|
Cobb, Thomas Reade Rootes |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: November 1, 1862
unconfirmed: died |
- He was a colonel who formed Cobb's Legion.
- He was mortally wounded at Fredericksburg in December 1862.
- His promotion to brigadier general was not confirmed before his death.
|
Dearing, James |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: April 29, 1864
not confirmed;
continued as brigade
commander |
- He was a colonel in the 8th Regular Cavalry.
- He was appointed brigadier general in April 1864, but it was not confirmed.
- He was mortally wounded in a duel in April 1865.
|
Deshler, James |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: July 28, 1863
not confirmed |
- He graduated from USMA in 1854.
- He was a colonel in the artillery.
- He was appointed brigadier general in July 1863, but it was not confirmed.
- He was killed by a shell at Chickamauga in September 1863.
|
Dunovant, John |
Colonel
Brigadier General (temporary)
rank: August 22, 1864
unconfirmed at death |
- He was a colonel in the 5th South Carolina Cavalry.
- He was appointed temporary brigadier general in August 1864.
- He was killed during the Siege of Petersburg in October 1864. His appointment was not confirmed before his death.
|
Fauntleroy, Thomas Turner |
Brigadier General,
Provisional Army of Virginia
Major
Refused brigadier general
appointment |
- He was a veteran of the War of 1812 and the Mexican–American War.
- He resigned as a colonel from the U.S. Army in May 1861.
- He was recommended for brigadier general in July 1861 but refused the appointment.
|
Fiser, John Calvin |
Colonel |
- He was a colonel in the 17th Mississippi Infantry.
- He lost his right arm at Knoxville in November 1863.
- His appointment as brigadier general was never confirmed.
|
Frazer, John W. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
nom or appt: May 3, 1863
rank: May 19, 1863
unconfirmed |
- He graduated from USMA in 1849.
- He was a colonel in the 28th Alabama Infantry.
- His brigadier general appointment was not confirmed.
- He was captured at Cumberland Gap, Tennessee, in September 1863.
|
Garrott, Isham Warren |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: May 28, 1863 |
- He was a colonel in the 20th Alabama Infantry.
- He was killed at Vicksburg in June 1863.
- His commission as brigadier general was received after his death and was not confirmed.
|
Girardey, Victor J. B. |
Brigadier General (temporary)
rank: July 30, 1864
commissioned:
August 3, 1864
unconfirmed? |
- Born in France in 1837.
- He was promoted to temporary brigadier general in July 1864 for his actions at the Battle of the Crater.
- He was killed in August 1864. Some sources say his appointment was not confirmed.
|
Godwin, Archibald C. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: August 5, 1864
unconfirmed |
- He was a colonel in the 57th North Carolina Infantry.
- He was killed at Third Winchester in September 1864. His appointment as brigadier general was not confirmed.
|
Goggin, James M. |
Major
Brigadier General
rank: December 4, 1864
cancelled
unconfirmed |
- He was a major who commanded a brigade at Cedar Creek.
- His brigadier general appointment in December 1864 was canceled and not confirmed.
|
Hagan, James |
Colonel |
- Born in Ireland in 1822.
- He was a colonel in the 3rd Alabama Cavalry.
- He was appointed acting brigadier general in early 1865, but his commission was never delivered.
|
Hannon, Moses Wright |
Colonel |
- He was a colonel in the 53rd Alabama Cavalry.
- He was appointed brigadier general in early 1865, but his commission was never delivered.
|
Harris, David Bullock |
Colonel |
- He was the Chief Engineer of the Confederate Army.
- He was said to have been verbally promoted to brigadier general by Jefferson Davis, but he died in 1864 before it could be processed.
|
Harrison Jr, George P. |
Colonel |
- He received a provisional appointment to brigadier general in 1865, but it was never officially confirmed before the war ended.
|
Hatton, Robert Hopkins |
Colonel
Brigadier General
not confirmed: died |
- He was a U.S. Representative before the war.
- He was a colonel in the 17th Tennessee Infantry.
- He was appointed brigadier general in May 1862 but was killed in action days later, so it was not confirmed.
|
Henderson, Robert Johnson |
Colonel |
- He was a colonel in the 42nd Georgia Infantry.
- He was promoted to acting brigadier general by General Joseph E. Johnston in March 1865, but it was not officially appointed or confirmed.
|
Hodge, George B. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
nominations rejected
paroled as brig. gen. |
- He was a colonel who led a cavalry brigade.
- He was nominated twice for brigadier general, but the Confederate Senate rejected his nominations.
- He was paroled as a brigadier general at the end of the war.
|
Johnson, Adam Rankin
"Stovepipe" |
Colonel
Brigadier General
(not confirmed) |
- He was a colonel in the 10th Kentucky Partisan Rangers.
- He was known for using "Quaker cannons" (stove pipes) to trick enemies.
- He was appointed brigadier general in September 1864, but it was not confirmed by the Senate.
- He was accidentally shot and blinded by his own men in August 1864.
|
Jones, John R. |
Lt. Colonel
Brigadier General
(not confirmed) |
- He was a lieutenant colonel in the 33rd Virginia Infantry.
- He was appointed brigadier general in June 1862, but his confirmation was postponed and never approved.
- He was relieved of command and later captured.
|
Martin, John Donelson |
Colonel
Acting Brigadier General
appointed April 29, 1862 |
- He was a colonel who commanded a brigade at Shiloh and Corinth.
- He was appointed acting brigadier general after Shiloh.
- He was mortally wounded and died at Corinth in October 1862.
|
Moore, Samuel Preston |
Colonel
Surgeon General |
- He was the Surgeon General of the Confederate Army.
- He is often mistakenly listed as a brigadier general, but proposals to give his position that rank failed.
|
Munford, Thomas Taylor |
Colonel
Assigned {Acting Brigadier General}
not commissioned/commission never received |
- He was a colonel in the 2nd Virginia Cavalry.
- He was assigned as a brigadier general in November 1864, but his official papers were never received.
- He commanded a cavalry division at the end of the war.
|
Northrop, Lucius B. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: November 26, 1864
nomination not sent
for Senate confirmation |
- He was the Commissary General of the Confederacy.
- He was appointed brigadier general in November 1864, but his nomination was never sent to the Senate for approval.
|
O'Neal, Edward Asbury |
Colonel
Brigadier General:
commission cancelled |
- He was a colonel in the 26th Alabama Infantry.
- He was wounded multiple times.
- His brigadier general commission was canceled by Robert E. Lee.
|
Pegram, William "Willie" |
Colonel
Acting brigadier general |
- He was a colonel in the artillery.
- He was an acting brigadier general in March 1865.
- He was mortally wounded at Five Forks in April 1865.
|
Phifer, Charles W. |
Major
Acting brigadier general
appt: May 25, 1862
canceled: October 16, 1862 |
- He was a major in the 6th Arkansas Cavalry Battalion.
- He was appointed acting brigadier general in May 1862, but the appointment was not confirmed and later canceled.
|
Porterfield, George |
Colonel
Acting Brigadier General |
- He was a colonel in the 25th Virginia Infantry.
- He was an acting brigadier general in command of the Department of Northwestern Virginia early in the war.
- He later resigned and took no further part in the war.
|
Rains, James Edwards |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank, nom: November 4, 1862
not confirmed, died |
- He was a colonel in the 11th Tennessee Infantry.
- He was killed at Stones River in December 1862. His promotion to brigadier general was not confirmed before his death.
|
Robertson, Felix Huston |
Colonel
Brigadier General (temporary)
rank: July 26, 1864
nom: rejected:
February 22, 1865 |
- He was a colonel in charge of artillery.
- He was appointed temporary brigadier general in July 1864, but his nomination was rejected by the Confederate Senate.
- He was severely wounded in November 1864.
- He was the only native Texan appointed a Confederate general, even though his appointment was rejected.
|
Rucker, Edmund Winchester |
Colonel
Brigadier General
(Acting) |
- He was nominated as acting brigadier general in November 1864, but it was not confirmed by the Confederate Congress.
|
Semmes, Raphael
"Beeswax", "Bim" |
Rear Admiral,
Confederate States Navy
Brigadier General
appointed April 5, 1865
(unconfirmed) |
- He was a famous Confederate Navy commander, known for the CSS Alabama.
- He was appointed a brigadier general by President Davis in April 1865 to command defenses, but it was not confirmed.
|
Taylor, Thomas H. |
Colonel
Brigadier General
unconfirmed |
- He was a colonel who commanded a brigade at Cumberland Gap.
- He was appointed brigadier general in November 1862, but President Davis did not nominate him to the Senate for that rank.
|
Thomas, Bryan Morel |
Colonel
Brigadier General
rank: August 4, 1864
not confirmed |
- He was a colonel who commanded a mixed brigade in the Department of the Gulf.
- He was appointed brigadier general in August 1864, but it was not confirmed.
|
Walker, Francis Marion |
Colonel |
- He was a colonel in the 19th Tennessee Infantry.
- He was killed at Atlanta in June 1864.
- His commission was received one day after his death and was not confirmed.
|
At the start of the Civil War, many states had their own military units called militias. In the Union, most state militias joined the federal army. But in the Confederacy, some states kept their militia units for local defense. Since many battles happened in the South, some of these state militia units, and their generals, saw a lot of fighting.
These generals were fighting for the Confederate cause and sometimes commanded many troops. However, they were officially state militia generals, not generals in the Confederate States Army.
Here are some important state militia generals from the Confederate States who led troops in battles or campaigns in their home states.
Name |
Rank |
Notes |
Alcorn, James Lusk |
Brigadier General, Mississippi Militia |
- He was a brigadier general of the Mississippi State militia.
- He was captured at Helena, Arkansas, and later exchanged.
|
Anderson, Charles David |
Brigadier General, Georgia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the 3rd Georgia Militia brigade.
- His brigade fought in the Atlanta campaign and against Sherman's March to the Sea.
- He was wounded at Griswoldville in November 1864.
|
Boggs, James |
Brigadier General, Virginia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the Provisional Army of Virginia.
- He served in Jackson's Valley Campaign.
|
John T. Hughes |
Brigadier General, Missouri Militia |
- He was a colonel in the Missouri State Guard.
- He fought in battles like Carthage and Wilson's Creek.
- He was killed at the First Battle of Independence, Missouri, in August 1862. He was promoted to brigadier general after his death.
|
Carson, James Harvey |
Brigadier General, Virginia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the Virginia militia.
- He served in Jackson's Valley Campaign.
|
Carswell, Reuben Walker |
Brigadier General, Georgia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the 1st Brigade, Georgia militia.
- He served in the Atlanta campaign.
|
Chapman, Augustus A. |
Brigadier General, Virginia Militia |
- He was a U.S. Representative before the war.
- He was a brigadier general in the Virginia militia.
- He served in the Kanawha Campaign.
|
Chase, William Henry |
Major General, Florida Militia |
- He was a U.S. Army Major who designed many forts.
- As a Florida militia colonel, he demanded the surrender of Fort Pickens in January 1861.
|
Clark, Edward |
Brigadier General, Texas Militia
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He was the acting governor of Texas.
- He was a brigadier general of the Texas state militia in 1865.
- He was wounded at Pleasant Hill in April 1864.
|
Clark, John Bullock |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard |
- He was a U.S. Representative before the war.
- He was a brigadier general of the pro-Confederate Missouri State Guard.
- He was wounded at Wilson's Creek.
|
Clark, Meriwether Lewis Sr. |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He was the son of the famous explorer William Clark.
- He was a brigadier general in the Missouri State Guard.
- He was captured at Sailor's Creek.
|
Dahlgren, Charles G. |
Brigadier General, Mississippi Militia |
- He was the brother of Union Navy Admiral John A. Dahlgren.
- He was a brigadier general in the Mississippi State Troops.
|
de Saussure, Wilmot Gibbes |
Brigadier General, South Carolina Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the South Carolina militia.
- He served in the Second Battle of Charleston Harbor.
|
Ford, John Salmon |
Brigadier General, Texas Militia
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He was a Texas Ranger and a colonel in the Confederate Army.
- He was a brigadier general in the Texas militia.
- He commanded forces at the Battle of Palmito Ranch, the last battle of the Civil War.
|
Garlington, Albert Creswell |
Brigadier General, South Carolina Militia |
- He was a brigadier general and Adjutant General of the South Carolina militia.
- He served in the Carolinas campaign.
|
Greene, Colton |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard
Colonel, 3rd Missouri Cavalry (CSA)
Acting brigadier general (CSA) |
- He was a brigadier general in the Missouri State Guard.
- He was also an acting brigadier general in the Confederate States Army.
|
Harman, William Henry |
Brigadier General, Virginia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the Virginia militia.
- He commanded forces that seized Harper's Ferry.
- He was killed at Waynesboro, Virginia, in March 1865.
|
Harper, Kenton |
Major General, Virginia Militia |
- He was a major general in the Virginia militia.
- He also commanded forces that seized Harper's Ferry.
|
Harris, Jeptha Vining |
Brigadier General, Mississippi Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the Mississippi militia.
- He was captured at Vicksburg.
|
Harrison, Sr., George Paul |
Brigadier General, Georgia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the Georgia militia, involved in coastal defense.
- He was captured in December 1864.
|
McBride, James Haggin |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He was a brigadier general in the Missouri State Guard.
- He commanded the 7th Division at the Siege of Lexington, Missouri.
|
McCay, Henry Kent |
Brigadier General, Georgia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the 4th Brigade, Georgia Militia.
- He fought at Griswoldville.
|
Meem, Gilbert Simrall |
Brigadier General, Virginia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the Virginia militia.
- He served in Jackson's Valley Campaign.
|
Pearce, Nicholas Bartlett |
Brigadier General, Arkansas State Troops
Major, Confederate States Army |
- He was a brigadier general in the Arkansas State Troops.
- He served in the Commissary Department for the rest of the war.
|
Phillips, Pleasant J. |
Brigadier General, Georgia Militia |
- He was a brigadier general in the 2nd Brigade, Georgia militia.
- He served in the Atlanta campaign.
|
Rains, George W. |
Brigadier General, Georgia Militia
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He established and commanded the Confederate Powderworks.
- He was a brigadier general in the Georgia militia.
|
Smith, Francis Henney |
Brevet Brigadier General, Virginia Militia
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He was the Superintendent of the Virginia Military Institute (VMI).
- He was a brevet brigadier general in the Virginia militia.
- He led the VMI Corps of Cadets battalion in several actions.
|
Steen, Alexander E. |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard
Colonel, Confederate States Army |
- He was a brigadier general in the Missouri State Guard.
- He was killed at the Battle of Prairie Grove in December 1862.
|
Thompson, Meriwether Jefferson |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard |
- He was the mayor of St. Joseph, Missouri.
- He was a brigadier general in the Missouri State Guard.
- He surrendered at Chalk Bluff, Arkansas, in May 1865.
|
Tupper, Tulius Cicero |
Major General, Mississippi State Troops |
- He was commissioned as a major general of the Mississippi State Troops.
|
Watkins, Nathaniel W. |
Brigadier General, Missouri State Guard |
- He was a veteran of the War of 1812 and the Mexican–American War.
- He was a brigadier general in the Missouri State Guard.
|