Price–Anderson Nuclear Industries Indemnity Act facts for kids
.svg) |
|
| Long title | An Act to amend the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, and for other purposes. |
|---|---|
| Nicknames | Price-Anderson Act |
| Enacted by | the 85th United States Congress |
| Effective | September 2, 1957 |
| Citations | |
| Public law | 85-256 |
| Statutes at Large | 71 Stat. 576 |
| Codification | |
| Titles amended | 42 U.S.C.: Public Health and Social Welfare |
| U.S.C. sections created | 42 U.S.C. ch. 23 |
| Legislative history | |
|
|
The Price-Anderson Nuclear Industries Indemnity Act, often called the Price-Anderson Act, is a United States federal law. It was first created in 1957 and has been updated many times since. This law deals with who is responsible for costs if there's an accident at a non-military nuclear facility in the U.S.
The main goal of the Act is to help the nuclear industry by limiting how much they have to pay if an accident happens. At the same time, it makes sure that people affected by a nuclear accident get paid for their damages. It sets up a system where the nuclear industry pays the first part of any claims. If the costs are much higher, the U.S. government might step in to help cover the rest.
When the Act was first passed, it was important because private companies were worried about the huge costs of a nuclear accident. They felt the available insurance wasn't enough. The Act helped encourage these companies to build and operate nuclear power plants. In 1978, the Supreme Court said the Act was constitutional. The law was last updated in 2005 and will be in effect until 2025.
Contents
How the Price-Anderson Act Works
Paying for Accidents: Funding and Procedures
Nuclear power plant owners must buy the most insurance they can get for nuclear accidents. As of 2017, this was about $450 million for each reactor. If an accident happens, the insurance company pays claims up to this amount.
If the accident costs more than the insurance covers, a special fund called the Price-Anderson fund helps pay the rest. This fund is paid for by the nuclear power companies themselves. Each company agrees to pay a certain amount per reactor if a big accident happens. For example, as of 2013, each company might have to pay up to $121 million per reactor.
The total amount in this fund could be over $12 billion if all companies had to pay their full share. Companies don't pay into this fund until an accident actually happens. However, there are plans in place to quickly get money from loans so victims can be paid fast.
If a major accident occurs and the costs might go beyond the fund, the President must tell Congress. Congress would then decide how to raise more money to pay everyone affected. The law also covers facilities run by the Department of Energy (DOE). If an accident happens at a DOE facility, the U.S. government pays from its treasury.
Since the Act started, nuclear insurance groups have paid about $151 million in claims. This includes about $70 million for the 1979 Three Mile Island accident. The Department of Energy has also paid about $65 million for accidents at its own sites.
Special Rules for Court Cases
The Price-Anderson Act changes some normal court rules for nuclear accidents:
- All lawsuits from a nuclear accident automatically go to a federal court.
- All claims from the same accident are handled together in one federal court. This court makes sure that payments are fair, especially if there isn't enough money to cover everything.
- Companies cannot say the accident wasn't their fault to avoid paying damages.
- People have a long time to file a claim, usually three years from when they discover the damage.
- People cannot sue companies for extra "punishment" money (called punitive damages). However, companies can still face fines or criminal charges for breaking safety rules.
History of the Price-Anderson Act
Why the Law Was Created
The Price-Anderson Act is named after Representative Charles Melvin Price and Senator Clinton Presba Anderson. They both led the committee that handled atomic energy in Congress.
After World War II, the U.S. government wanted to use nuclear technology to make electricity. In 1954, a new law allowed private companies to operate nuclear power plants. But insurance companies couldn't offer enough coverage for the huge risks of a nuclear accident. No single company or group of companies could provide the needed insurance.
Electric companies were worried that one big accident could bankrupt them. Because of this, it seemed unlikely that private companies would want to get into the nuclear power business. To solve this problem, Congress created the Price-Anderson Act in 1957.
The Act required companies to get the most insurance they could, which was $60 million at the time. The government then promised an extra $500 million to cover any costs beyond that. This meant companies wouldn't be responsible for costs beyond the insured amount. The Act was meant to be temporary, lasting only ten years. It was hoped that by then, companies would have a good safety record and could get enough private insurance. Insurance companies responded by forming groups like American Nuclear Insurers (ANI) to offer more coverage.
How the Law Has Changed Over Time
By 1966, it was clear that nuclear companies still couldn't get enough private insurance. So, the Act was extended until 1976. New rules were added to make it easier for victims to get money from companies. For example, companies couldn't argue that an accident wasn't their fault.
In 1975, the Act was extended for another 12 years. The total insurance amount stayed the same, but each nuclear reactor had to contribute more money if an accident happened. This meant the government no longer had to put money into the insurance pool. However, Congress promised that if a very large accident occurred, they would do whatever was needed to pay everyone affected.
The Act was extended again in 1988 for 15 years. The amount of insurance each power plant needed to have increased to $200 million. The total fund grew to $9.5 billion. Small reactors, like those used for research, also got specific coverage. This extension also made sure all cases from a nuclear accident would be heard in a federal court.
In 2002 and 2003, the Act was temporarily extended. Then, in 2005, it was extended again through 2025 as part of the Energy Policy Act of 2005. The individual insurance for each site went up to $300 million, and fund contributions per reactor increased to $95.8 million.
How the Law Has Been Used
For the first 43 years of the Price-Anderson Act (up to 2000), the extra insurance fund was not needed. About $151 million was paid out from the primary insurance, including $71 million for the Three Mile Island accident. The Department of Energy also paid about $65 million for its nuclear operations during that time.
Is the Price-Anderson Act Constitutional?
In June 1978, the Supreme Court decided that the Price-Anderson Act was constitutional. This happened in a case called Duke Power Co. v. Carolina Environmental Study Group.
The lawsuit argued two main things:
- The Act didn't promise enough money for accident victims, which might go against the Fifth Amendment.
- It treated nuclear accidents differently from other accidents, which might go against the Fourteenth Amendment.
The Supreme Court decided that:
- The Act's goal was to help private companies develop nuclear energy while still making sure the public got paid if a big accident happened.
- Limiting how much companies had to pay was a reasonable way to encourage them to get involved in nuclear power.
- The Act offered a fair way for people to get paid, replacing older state laws.
- The Act did not make companies careless about safety. If an accident happened, the power company would still lose a lot of money.
- The promise of a large fund (then $560 million) and Congress's commitment to help was a fair way to ensure people got paid.
- Treating nuclear accidents differently was okay because it helped encourage nuclear energy development.
How Nuclear Power Compares to Other Industries
The nuclear industry isn't the only one with special rules for accidents.
- For example, in the U.S., oil companies pay a small fee for each barrel of oil. This money goes into a fund that can pay for oil spill damages, up to a certain limit.
- The hydroelectric industry (dams that make electricity) is generally not held fully responsible for huge disasters like a dam breaking. For example, after the Teton Dam failed in Idaho in 1977, causing $500 million in damage, the dam operators were not held responsible.
While many industries don't have a specific limit on how much they can be sued for, in reality, a company's responsibility might be limited to its total money and property. Also, it can be hard to prove who is at fault without specific laws.
Criticisms of the Act
Many groups, like the Union of Concerned Scientists and Greenpeace International, have criticized the Price-Anderson Act.
- Some critics say the Act makes nuclear power seem less risky than it is.
- They also argue that it doesn't make nuclear power plants carry enough insurance. This could mean taxpayers would have to pay most of the bill if a major accident happened.
- Some economists have estimated that the government insurance support is worth millions of dollars to nuclear power plants each year.
- The Act has also been called "corporate welfare" by some, meaning it's a special benefit for corporations.
Another criticism is that the Act protects Department of Energy facilities and private companies from nuclear incidents, even if there was serious carelessness. Critics say no other government agency offers this much protection to non-government workers. However, the Energy Department argues that the harm to the public would be the same no matter who was at fault.
It's important to remember that the risk of huge, unexpected costs is not unique to nuclear power. Like nuclear power, hydroelectric power plants are also not fully insured against massive disasters. For these kinds of major accidents, the government often steps in to provide insurance.
