Foie gras controversy facts for kids
.jpg)
Foie gras is the special liver of a duck or goose that has been made very fatty. This happens because the birds are given more food than they would normally eat. This feeding method is called gavage. The food is usually corn cooked with fat, which helps the birds swallow it easily. This process makes the liver very fatty, which is what some chefs and food lovers want. However, how foie gras is made is a big topic of debate.
Contents
Concerns from Animal Welfare Groups
Groups that protect animals, like the Humane Society of the United States and PETA, believe that making foie gras is cruel to animals. They say that force-feeding makes the birds' livers grow to more than ten times their normal size. This can hurt the liver's ability to work properly. Also, the birds' stomachs get so big that it's hard for them to walk. If the force-feeding continues, the birds can even die. Sometimes, their throats can get scarred.
In modern foie gras farming, force-feeding happens for about 12 to 18 days before the birds are ready for slaughter.
In 2003, a French group called Stopgavage asked judges to say that foie gras production breaks animal welfare laws. They claimed to have support from many animal rights groups around the world.
Some researchers have also criticized studies that say force-feeding is not harmful. They believe these studies might be influenced by the foie gras industry.
In 2005, groups like APRL, IDA, and PETA released videos. These videos, narrated by actor Roger Moore, showed what happens inside foie gras farms in the U.S. and France. PETA wants this practice to stop, and many famous people have supported their campaign.
Opinions from Veterinary Experts
In 2004 and 2005, the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), which is a main group for vets in the U.S., looked into the methods used to make foie gras. After hearing from many vets, they decided not to take a strong stand against it. They stated that there was "minimum of adverse effects on the birds involved."
Some vets who visited foie gras farms said that the birds seemed well cared for. One vet even said that tube feeding was less stressful for the birds than taking a cat's temperature. They felt that decisions should be based on science, not just feelings.
However, some critics say that the AVMA often supports big farming businesses instead of animal welfare. They point out that the AVMA has also not taken a stand against other controversial farming methods.
Different Views on Foie Gras Production
In 2005, a writer for The New York Times, Lawrence Downes, visited a foie gras farm. He said he "saw no pain or panic" when the birds were fed with a tube. He felt the practice was "neither particularly gentle nor particularly rough."
But Dr. Ward Stone, a wildlife expert, studied ducks that died from force-feeding. He said that the short, difficult lives of ducks raised for foie gras were "well outside the norm of farm practice." He strongly recommended that this practice should be made illegal.
In 2009, a group called the National Advertising Division (NAD) told a foie gras producer to stop saying their product came from "enlarged" rather than "diseased" livers. They also had to stop claiming the animals were "hand-raised with tender care" because they couldn't prove it.
What Producers and Chefs Say
Most foie gras producers say their methods are not cruel. They believe it's a natural process that uses the birds' natural abilities. They argue that wild ducks and geese eat a lot and gain weight before they migrate. Producers also claim that ducks and geese don't have a gag reflex like humans, so force-feeding doesn't bother them.
Some chefs, like Anthony Bourdain, have supported foie gras if the ducks are treated well. But other famous chefs, like Wolfgang Puck, are against using foie gras. Chef Albert Roux thinks foie gras should have a warning label so people know how the animals are treated. He believes more humane methods should be used.
Legal Challenges and Bans
The debate over foie gras has led to many lawsuits and bans in different places.
In 2011, the Animal Legal Defense Fund asked the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to add a warning label to foie gras products. They wanted it to say: "NOTICE: Foie gras products are derived from diseased birds." They argued that selling foie gras without this warning was misleading. They also pointed out that eating foie gras could be harmful to people with certain health conditions like Alzheimer's or type 2 diabetes.
In 2012, the Animal Legal Defense Fund sued a foie gras company for advertising its product as "the humane choice." The company later stopped this advertising.
Bans Around the World
Many countries and regions have banned the production or sale of foie gras due to animal welfare concerns.
India
In July 2014, India became the first country to ban the import of foie gras. This was a big win for animal welfare groups.
Australia and Argentina
Australia has banned the production of foie gras, but it's still legal to import it. Argentina banned foie gras production in 2003, calling it animal cruelty.
Brazil
In June 2015, the city of São Paulo in Brazil banned the production and sale of foie gras in restaurants. However, this law was later overturned in 2016.
Europe
Since 1997, the number of European countries making foie gras has dropped by half. As of 2016, only five European countries still produce it: Belgium, Bulgaria, France, Hungary, and Spain.
Many European countries have banned foie gras production or the force-feeding method. These include Austria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, Norway, Poland, Turkey, and the United Kingdom. Even if production is banned, it can still be imported and bought in most of these countries.
In France, a law states that "Foie gras belongs to the protected cultural and gastronomical heritage of France."
Israel
In 2003, the Supreme Court of Israel ordered a ban on force-feeding geese, which went into effect in 2005. This ban was put in place to stop animal cruelty.
United States
California
California passed a law in 2004 that made it illegal to force-feed birds to enlarge their livers and to sell products made this way. This law went into effect in 2012. There have been legal challenges to this law, but it was upheld in 2017.
In 2008, the San Diego City Council encouraged people to avoid supporting foie gras, calling force-feeding a "cruel practice."
Illinois
In 2006, the Chicago City Council voted to ban the sale of foie gras. Some chefs continued to sell it, and the ban caused a lot of debate. The mayor of Chicago, Richard M. Daley, even called it "the silliest law." In 2008, the Chicago City Council voted to end the ban.
New York
In October 2019, the New York City Council voted to ban foie gras made by force-feeding by the year 2022.
Retailer Bans
Many stores have stopped selling foie gras after protests and campaigns against its production methods. These include Amazon UK, Waitrose, Sainsbury's, Lidl, and Harvey Nichols.
Images for kids
-
Gavage feeding
-
Anti-foie gras protestors at the Hôtel Meurice, Paris
See also
In Spanish: Controversia sobre la elaboración del foie gras para niños
