Alternative law in Ireland prior to 1921 facts for kids
Alternative legal systems were used by Irish nationalist groups starting in the 1760s. These groups wanted to challenge British rule in Ireland. Groups like the Whiteboys, Irish National Land League, and later Sinn Féin created their own rules.
These alternative systems were often linked to farmer protests. They filled a gap because the official British government never had full support from the Irish people. People who opposed British rule wanted to create a system based on Irish law, not English law. They hoped this would eventually replace British authority.
Contents
Why Alternative Laws?
Many Irish people saw British law as something forced upon them. They did not see it as fair or right. For a long time, Irish law (called Brehon law) existed alongside English law. But English law became more dominant.
Laws were written and spoken in English. However, most Irish people only spoke Irish. This made it hard for them to understand the legal system. The Penal Laws also limited the rights of Catholics until the 1830s.
British land laws protected landowners, but often ignored Irish traditions. For example, they didn't respect a tenant's right to stay on their land. Local courts were run by unpaid landlords, not fair officials. This made people trust the system even less. For instance, a man who only spoke Irish was wrongly convicted because he couldn't understand the court. Because of these issues, the British government struggled to rule Ireland effectively. This led to the rise of alternative legal systems.
The "Unwritten Law"
Many Irish small farmers believed in an "unwritten law." This was a deep-rooted idea that access to land for farming was a basic human right. They felt this right was more important than official property laws. They believed the right to use land was passed down through families. It should not depend on whether someone could pay rent.
This idea was similar to old Brehon law. Brehon law did not see land ownership as absolute. Farmers believed the land of Ireland belonged to the Irish people. They felt it had been taken by English invaders. So, Irish tenants saw the landlord-tenant system as unfair and wanted to end it.
An important person in this idea was James Fintan Lalor (1807–1849). He believed that Irish farmers had the first right to their own land. Lalor said a farmer should use his crop for food and seeds first. Only then could others claim part of the harvest. He advised Irish people to refuse to obey British law. Instead, they should set up their own government and refuse to pay rent to landlords. Lalor's ideas greatly influenced the Irish National Land League in the 1880s.
Secret Societies and Their Rules
Secret societies like the Whiteboys started in the 1760s. They were groups of people who swore oaths to each other. The Threshers, another group, focused on economic issues. They tried to control prices and reduce fees charged by churches.
Ribbon societies began in the 1810s. They started in northern Ireland to fight against Protestant groups. But they soon focused on land issues and spread across the country. These secret societies often appeared during tough economic times for farmers. They would disappear when times were better.
Historians believe these groups used violence as a form of "retributive justice." This meant they punished people who broke their traditional land rules. People who broke their oaths to the society could also be targeted. Murders were rare, but they did happen.
These societies didn't have formal court systems. But if someone was accused of breaking their rules, they could be "tried" by the local society. This often happened without the accused person being present. One official noted that there were "two codes of law in force." One was the official British law, which people didn't trust. The other was a secret law enforced by the societies.
The Repeal Association's Courts
In 1843, Daniel O'Connell announced that his large group, the Repeal Association, would set up its own court system. This was part of his plan to create an Irish government. These courts would be run by people who supported the Repeal movement. They would also include individuals chosen by local religious leaders.
The plan was for these courts to have no fees. People who agreed to use the court had to obey its decision. If they didn't, they would be removed from the Repeal Association. These courts became very popular. Their popularity worried the British government. O'Connell was arrested and charged with conspiracy because of these tribunals.
After the Great Famine (1845–1849), the Repeal Association weakened. Secret societies then took over the role of settling land and wage disputes. Sometimes, local priests also organized arbitration courts. They would refuse religious services to those who didn't follow a court's decision.
Land League Courts
The Irish National Land League (1879–1882) was a national group that protested for farmers' rights. They wanted fair rent, the right to sell improvements on their land, and secure land ownership. Their ultimate goal was for farmers to own the land they worked.
Some local Land League groups set up their own courts in 1880 and 1881. These courts usually had a committee that heard cases. They would call both sides, listen to witnesses, and look at evidence. Then, they would make a judgment and decide on a penalty. Sometimes, juries from the local community were used. These courts were similar to British courts in some ways. One newspaper even said that the Land League court in Athenry had more cases than the local British court.
Historians describe these courts as a "shadow legal system." They were seen as a major challenge to British rule. The Land League's formation of courts was considered "the most unacceptable of all acts of defiance" by the British.
One of the League's main tactics was the boycott. This meant refusing to deal with people who broke the rules, especially "land grabbers" (people who took land from evicted tenants). The word "boycott" came from a successful campaign against an unpopular land agent named Charles Boycott.
The Land League's power grew because many people refused to cooperate with the official British justice system. People would turn to the Land League to solve their problems instead of British magistrates. If someone followed British law, they might be criticized for breaking the "unwritten code." Many observers believed the Land League was not just a competing government, but the only effective one in many parts of Ireland.
National League and United Irish League Courts
The Irish National League (1882–1910) replaced the Land League. It was a more moderate group. Its rules included forbidding paying rent without reductions and taking over land from evicted tenants. They also banned buying land under certain conditions unless the price was very low.
The League enforced its rules with informal courts. These were usually led by local leaders. These courts held their meetings openly and followed a process similar to British common law. This helped the League show it supported the rule of law, but Irish law. Many people at the time saw the National League as a real authority. Officials even agreed that the League's decisions were instantly obeyed in some areas.
The United Irish League (1898–1910) was another protest group. It focused on redistributing land from large landowners to small farmers. If a compromise couldn't be reached, the landowner would be called to a meeting. Refusing to attend resulted in a boycott, the League's highest penalty.
Local UIL branches acted as courts. They claimed power over all land matters in their area. People accused of breaking the League's rules would be called to a meeting. Evidence would be heard, a decision made, and a punishment given. This process was very similar to British local courts. The UIL tried to be fair and impartial to encourage people to use their courts. Their decisions were even published in local newspapers.
Police reports showed many boycotts and cases of intimidation used to enforce the UIL's decisions. The harshest punishments were for "land-grabbers." One inspector general said in 1907 that "The law of the land has been openly set aside and the unwritten law of the League is growing supreme."
Dáil Courts
The Sinn Féin party started setting up arbitration courts after 1917. Party leader Arthur Griffith said that every Irishman should obey these courts instead of British courts. Sinn Féin liked these courts because they promoted self-reliance. Arbitration between two parties was legal and binding if both sides agreed to the verdict.
Unlike the older secret society courts, Sinn Féin's courts claimed power over crimes and followed a written constitution. After the 1918 Irish general election, Sinn Féin members refused to take their seats in the British Parliament. Instead, they set up the Dáil Éireann, a rival Irish parliament.
In August 1919, during the Irish War of Independence, the Dáil announced a national court system for its new Irish Republic. This system included local parish courts, district courts, and a court of appeal. Parish courts handled small crimes and civil cases. They offered cheap and easy access to justice. Local judges were elected, and all officials were paid.
At first, these courts were supposed to be voluntary. But soon, their decisions were enforced by the Irish Republican Army (IRA). The Dáil Courts became very popular. They were seen as a major success for the First Dáil (the first Irish parliament). They were known for being fair, and even some unionists (who supported British rule) respected them.
The Dáil Courts also took over control of other local courts, including those dealing with land issues. By 1921, using British courts was seen as "assisting the enemy." The IRA attacked anyone connected with the British legal system. Many British judges and police resigned. The British government lost control of much of Ireland. Even when the British government tried to shut down the Dáil Courts, they continued to operate secretly.
After the 1921 Anglo-Irish Treaty, British courts were handed over to the new Irish Free State. However, the Dáil court system was eventually shut down and declared illegal in 1923.
See Also
- Paramilitary punishment attacks in Northern Ireland
- Vigilantism in Northern Ireland during and after the Troubles
- Early Irish law
- March law (Ireland)
