Bruno Bauer facts for kids
Quick facts for kids
Bruno Bauer
|
|
|---|---|
.jpg)
Photograph of Bruno Bauer, c. 1870
|
|
| Born | 6 September 1809 Eisenberg, Saxe-Gotha-Altenburg
|
| Died | 13 April 1882 (aged 72) Rixdorf, Berlin, German Empire
|
| Alma mater | Friedrich Wilhelm University |
| Era | 19th-century philosophy |
| Region | Western philosophy |
| School | Rationalism Young Hegelians (early) |
|
Main interests
|
Theology, politics |
|
Notable ideas
|
Early Christianity owed more to Stoicism than to Judaism |
|
Influences
|
|
|
Influenced
|
|
Bruno Bauer (6 September 1809 – 13 April 1882) was an important German thinker. He was a philosopher and a theologian, which means he studied big ideas about life, knowledge, and religion. Bauer was a student of G. W. F. Hegel, a very famous philosopher.
Bauer was known for his strong belief in Rationalism. This idea says that reason and logic are the main ways to get knowledge. He used this approach to study the New Testament part of the Bible. He thought that early Christianity was more influenced by ancient Greek philosophy, especially Stoicism, than by Judaism.
He also had a close, but complicated, relationship with famous thinkers like Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Later in his life, he became friends with Max Stirner and influenced Friedrich Nietzsche. Starting in 1840, Bauer began to write that Jesus of Nazareth was a mix of Jewish, Greek, and Roman ideas from the 2nd century.
Contents
Who Was Bruno Bauer?
Early Life and Education
Bruno Bauer was born in Eisenberg, a town in Germany. His father was a painter in a porcelain factory. Bauer studied at the Friedrich Wilhelm University in Berlin from 1828 to 1832.
He became part of a group called the "Right Hegelians." These were followers of the philosopher Hegel. Bauer even helped edit a famous work by Hegel called "Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion." This became one of Bauer's most well-known projects.
In 1834, he started teaching theology in Berlin. Later, in 1839, he moved to the University of Bonn.
Bauer's Early Writings
In 1838, Bauer published a book called "Critical Exhibition of the Religion of the Old Testament." This book showed his strong belief in Hegelian Rationalism. He used reason to explain all miracles in the Bible in a natural way.
He continued this theme in 1840 with "Critique of the Evangelical History of John." In 1841, he wrote "Critique of the Evangelical History of the Synoptics."
From his early days, Bauer was not a traditional Christian. He always used Hegel's ideas and his own rational thinking to look at religious texts.
Friendships and Conflicts
From 1839 to 1841, Bauer was a teacher and friend to Karl Marx. But in 1841, their friendship ended. Marx, along with Friedrich Engels, developed ideas about socialism and communism that Bauer did not agree with. Marx and Engels later wrote two books, The Holy Family (1845) and The German Ideology (1846), to show their disagreement with Bauer.
Bauer was also involved in debates with other thinkers. Some people called him a "Right Hegelian," while others, because of his early leadership of the Young Hegelians, called him a "Left Hegelian." These labels were given to him by others; he never used them for himself.
Losing His Teaching Job
Bauer was sent to the University of Bonn by a government minister to protect his rational ideas and spread Hegelianism. However, Bauer made many enemies at Bonn University because he openly taught Rationalism. He even wrote in letters that he wanted to cause a scandal. He hoped this would force the government to either allow professors full freedom to teach or show their anti-enlightenment views by firing him.
In 1840, the pro-Hegelian minister died and was replaced by someone who opposed Hegel's ideas. Most theology departments said that a professor of Protestant theology should not teach "atheism." Since Bauer refused to change his rational views, the government took away his teaching license in 1842.
After the revolutions of 1848, Bauer left the city. He lived a simple life in the countryside near Berlin.
Later Writings
Even after losing his job, Bauer continued to write many books. He wrote about theology, history, and politics. He published them himself while working at his family's tobacco shop.
Some of his important later works include:
- "History of Politics, Culture and Enlightenment in the 18th Century" (1843–1845)
- "History of the French Revolution" (1847)
- "A Critique of the Gospels and a History of their Origin" (1850–1852)
- "Critique of the Pauline Epistles" (1850–1852)
- "Christ and the Caesars" (1879)
In these books, Bauer was a leader in studying the Bible using historical and literary criticism. His last book on theology, "Christ and the Caesars," aimed to show that Christian ideas were influenced by Greek and Roman philosophy as much as by Judaism.
Bruno Bauer died in 1882.
Bauer's Ideas on Christian Origins
The Gospels as Literature
Bauer studied the New Testament very closely. He disagreed with another scholar, David Strauss, who thought the Gospels were like myths created by early Christian groups. Bauer believed that only a single writer could create a connected story like the Gospels. He thought the Gospel of Mark was the first one written.
For Bauer, the Gospel of Mark was finished around 117–138 CE. He believed that all the other Gospels, like Matthew and Luke, used Mark as their model.
He also thought that some parts of the Gospel of Mark seemed like fiction. For example, the idea of the Messianic Secret, where Jesus tells people not to tell anyone about his miracles, seemed like a made-up story to Bauer. He believed the person who added this idea was the final editor of the Gospel of Mark.
Paul's Letters and Greek Influence
Bauer went even further, suggesting that all of Paul's letters were written later in the 2nd century. He thought they were written in the West and were against the ideas of Paul as shown in The Acts.
Bauer noticed that Greek and Roman ideas were very strong in early Christian writings. He provided a lot of historical evidence to support his theory. He believed that Christianity was basically Stoicism (a Greek philosophy) dressed up in Jewish ideas.
He also reviewed European literature from the 1st century. He found many key ideas from the New Testament in Greek and Roman writings of that time. This led him to believe that New Testament writers might have borrowed ideas from thinkers like Seneca the Younger, a Roman Stoic philosopher.
Judaism's Influence in Rome
In his book "Christ and the Caesars," Bauer argued that Judaism became very influential in Rome during the time of the Maccabees. He used 1st-century writings to show that Jewish influence in Rome was much greater than historians had thought. He pointed to the relationships between Jewish leaders like Herod and Josephus with Roman emperors.
Bauer believed that Roman emperors like Julius Caesar and Augustus Caesar tried to make their own lives seem like special, almost miraculous, stories. He said that Virgil's Aeneid helped make Augustus seem like a divine figure. Similarly, he thought that Vespasian's reign was linked to a special prophecy by Josephus, which made the Roman conquest of Judea seem more important.
Bauer's View on Jesus' Existence
Bruno Bauer was the first person to argue in a detailed way that Jesus might not have existed as a historical person.
However, earlier in his career, Bauer believed that Jesus did exist. He thought that traditional theologians had added too many legends to the real, historical Jesus. He wanted to "save the honor of Jesus" by removing these legends and showing Jesus' true connection to history.
But by 1841, in his "Criticism of the Gospel History of the Synoptics," Bauer began to argue that the Biblical Jesus was mainly a literary character. He questioned whether a historical Jesus existed at all. In his 1851 work, "Criticism of the Gospels and History of their Origin," and then in 1879 in "Christ and the Caesars," he proposed that the Gospel writers freely used Greek and Roman stories to create their accounts of Jesus.
Bauer's ideas were part of a larger movement called Bible Rationalism in the early 1800s. This movement, which included Hegel, focused on the historical setting and the teachings of Jesus, rather than supernatural events.
In his 1850–1852 works, Bauer concluded that there was no historical Jesus. He believed that everything known about Jesus "belongs to the world of imagination" of the Christian community.
His work was criticized at the time, and he lost his teaching job. However, his ideas were still discussed throughout Europe in the 19th century.
What Is Bruno Bauer's Legacy?
Bauer's work was largely forgotten by German universities for a while. But later, scholars like Albert Kalthoff brought his ideas back into attention. Kalthoff revived Bauer's theory that Jesus might be a myth in his books "The Problem of Christ" (1902) and "The Rise of Christianity" (1904).
Arthur Drews also supported Bauer's views, saying that Christianity came from Romans who needed hope against the powerful emperors, not from Jerusalem. He believed that the Gospels showed a new idea of freedom and were influenced by the Roman Empire's oppression. Drews concluded that a historical Jesus was not needed to explain the origin of the Gospel of Mark.
Today, the idea that Jesus did not exist (called the Christ myth theory) is considered a fringe theory by most scholars. This means it is not widely accepted in academic circles. Critics say these theories often lack strong evidence and rely on weak comparisons to other myths.
However, some people still argue that Bauer's ideas are important. They say he didn't deny Jesus' existence but questioned the legends and miracles about him. They believe he focused on the historical context and teachings of Jesus, like other rationalist thinkers.
Images for kids
-
Photograph of Bruno Bauer, c. 1870
See also
In Spanish: Bruno Bauer para niños
